Customer Sign In⚪Call Tracker

Recent Reviews (Page 26)

Posted 531 days ago.
Jonathan in Appleton on 11/09/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Jonathan said: It was a pleasure working with Nuegi. He answered all my questions with expertise and patience. Very happy with the tune-up!
Posted 531 days ago.
Richard in Neenah on 11/09/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Richard said: Tech was very nice and polite. He answered all my questions and seemed to be well trained in his job. Efficient and timely. Kept area clean and informed me at the end what he did and the condition of my furnace. Very satisfied with his service.
Posted 532 days ago.
Jeremy in Menasha on 11/09/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Jeremy said: Matt came and did a furnace checkup for me today. He was awesome. Explained how multiple items in my system worked so I understood and was did a great job. So glad I use you for my maintenance!
Posted 532 days ago.
Jim in Neenah on 11/09/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Jim said: Evan is always courteous, thorough and efficient. I also appreciate the online self scheduling.
Posted 532 days ago.
Albert & Sandra in Appleton on 11/08/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Posted 533 days ago.
Joe & Mary Beth in Appleton on 11/08/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Posted 533 days ago.
Andi in Menasha on 11/07/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Andi said: I give high marks to our technician given the chronic problems we have had with our York furnace. Also, appreciated his "can do" attitude/approach to addressing this particular instance with our York furnace...It just can't be fun providing maintenance knowing the unit will inevitably break down in the future and he will be back again...
Posted 533 days ago.
Jim in Appleton on 11/07/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Jim said: Neugi was on time, friendly and efficient.Thank you!
Posted 537 days ago.
Anthony in Appleton on 11/03/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Anthony said: Evan was extremely courteous & thorough during the inspection of our furnaces. Answered all of my silly questions.
Posted 537 days ago.
Karen in Menasha on 11/03/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Karen said: Dilan was on time and very knowledgeable. I highly recommend The Good Guys for service.
Posted 538 days ago.
Leanne in Sherwood on 11/02/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Leanne said: James was right on time and very professional. It is nice to have the same technician each year.
Posted 538 days ago.
Victoria in Appleton on 11/02/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Victoria said: Thanks to Matt for his swift and accurate care of my furnace & water heater! And for his help with my pellet gun!
Only request / reminder I have is for techs to use booties when entering homes. God Bless you all!
Posted 539 days ago.
Chris in Appleton on 11/02/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Chris said: Top notch service!
Posted 539 days ago.
Westscot & Jane in Appleton on 11/02/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Westscot & Jane said: Eric is very pleasant and efficient ! He explains the services provided well.
Posted 539 days ago.
Angel & Irma in Menasha on 11/01/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Posted 541 days ago.
Ryan in Appleton on 10/30/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Ryan said: Last year, when Good Guys inspected our furnace we were told the was a bearing failing and the furnace would need to be replaced. This year there is no bearing issue and the furnace is fine. Technician this year said the blower capacitor was
bad and the blower would not work. I declined as I would install one myself and when I tested the capacitor using a multimeter it was fine and within the rating for the unit. Also charging $77 to replace a $10 part that takes two minutes to change is ridiculous.
Company Response: Ryan, thanks for sharing your input on these visits. The $77 to change a $10 part taking two minutes is really missing what costs we are enduring. A service department has a lot of people to keep on payroll to keep things going. Doing Tune-Ups only would put us out of business. Our guys are paid well for their years of training and knowledge, and the cost to keep a fleet going with maintenance, part stocks, employee benefits, insurance, and us backing our work with customers all costs money.

In that $77 it covers the part, the labor, the knowledge knowing if it wasn't that you would not have to pay it and we would come back at no cost, and by us making the repair we have liability. Imagine taking your vehicle to a mechanic, where I recall a $26 part was replaced for $135 on one of our trucks. It's not ridiculous, skilled labor and a company backing their work is worth something. The customer always has the right to do the repair themselves, and we're one of the few companies I know that will sell a majority of parts over the counter to customers. Our large help center should help cement that we are for homeowners being able to repair their own equipment if they want to.

That being said, the capacitor was tested and showed 4.6 microfarad in 2022, and it was tested again on this visit. The one that's in there should be near 7.5 microfarad (+/- 10%). Depending when you test it in a cycle it can also read differing values.

In regards to the bearing issue. Our tech had to have heard something when he was there. Bearing issues can be intermittent especially if it's early with light wear damage. Keep an eye on it, and know that at some point it may get worse and eventually seize up.

Our technicians are not incentivized in any way to encourage repairs. They mentioned the repairs because they believed you really need them. The last two techs that came to your home are incredibly honest and talented guys.
Posted 541 days ago.
Jeff & Diane in Hortonville on 10/30/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Posted 544 days ago.
Mary in Neenah on 10/27/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Posted 544 days ago.
Jeff & Darlene in Kaukauna on 10/27/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Jeff & Darlene said: Friendly tech with a good attitude!
Posted 544 days ago.
Matthew in Appleton on 10/27/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Posted 544 days ago.
Steve & Lee in Menasha on 10/27/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Steve & Lee said: Matt was very polite and informative about addressing our aging furnace issues. Not at all pushy, just honest and helpful
Appreciate it, thanks !
Posted 544 days ago.
Carol in Menasha on 10/27/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Carol said: Matt called and asked if he could come a little early as he was nearby. He was friendly, helpful, efficient and very pleasant.
Posted 545 days ago.
Jeff & Kathy in Appleton on 10/27/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Posted 545 days ago.
Laura in Appleton on 10/27/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Laura said: Dilan was very nice and got right to work. My dog loved the extra pets from him as well.
Posted 545 days ago.
Sarah in Appleton on 10/27/23
Verified Customer

Overall
Value
Timeliness
Quality
Sarah said: He was super helpful and went way above and beyond to look everything over and even suggested recommendations that haven’t been mentioned in previous visits.
<< Previous Page Next Page >>
The name trusted by over 32,000 homeowners in the Fox Valley. A fifth generation family tradition, since the 1920s.

Award Winning Customer Service, Seal of Goodness Guarantee since 1966. No Pressure Promise! We do not utilize any high pressure tactics in our sales process, ever.

Address: 4450 W Greenville Drive. Appleton, WI 54913
Phone: (920) 734-1436 Fax: (920) 734-0929
Hours of Operation: 8:00a to 4:30p (Mon-Fri)

©2025 Christensen & Wisnet Inc. (d/b/a) The Good Guys Heating & Cooling

Privacy Policy | No Pressure Promise | Careers / Jobs

Employee: Office Email | Payroll Login | Sales Login | ServiceDesk | System Status